top of page

Search Results

Search this site

223 results found with an empty search

  • Mertzon City Council November 16 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting A municipality in Texas has authority to regulate with ordinances. Two ordinances that could have restricted this development are a right of way access easement and a height restriction ordinance. A. Agenda Analysis Selection of 391 Council Members, item 6: I did some research last week for what the County needed to do on this point, and I came upon the requirement at 391.006 that puts the onus of choosing membership on the "participating governmental units". Thus, like the City is doing here, the Irion County Commissioner's Court must select their members on this new commission. (This is not an appointment power of the Mayor or County Judge, alone.) Community Service, item 8: On occasion, the City will be the recipient of court ordered community service. Working with the individuals ordered to do court ordered service is entirely discretionary on the part of the City. If I recall recent discussions correctly, the intent here is to limit this service to non violent offenders. FFA Presentation, item 5: If you need a little hope that maybe the internet hasn't baked the brains of our youth, this competition practice is for you. This year they are debating landowner rights and data centers. The community needs to protect the viewshed of this building. B. Meeting Review Pending C. Commentary Cell tower update: I went to the Irion County Courthouse to research the agreement the landowners made with Skyway Towers. (Such sale or lease agreements involving land must be recorded in the District Clerk's office.) This Skyway lease is a five year lease starting on December 1, 2025, with 10 successive 5 year renewal options. In other words, it is potentially a 55 year lease. Equally important is that if the landowner ever wishes to sell the property, they have to give right of first refusal to purchase to Skyway. Skyway for 55 years gets an option to purchase the land the currently incomplete tower sits on. With no municipal development restrictions in place by the City of Mertzon, this means that potentially Skyway - and likely its successor - can build anything they want on the property should they ever own it. I'm not sure why a homeowner would ever take such a risk with adjacent vacant property they owned, as it potentially places a 55 year cloud on the value of their home. Equally important, the community has to potentially absorb the decrease in property values and diminished aesthetics. It is a lose/lose situation for the landowner and the community. One way to discourage this kind of development (in a neighborhood setting!) is to ask the City Council to develop reasonable ordinances that protect the beauty, health, safety and welfare of the community. Reasonable ordinances will not significantly impair the property rights of landowners, while at the same time protect the community. Another cell tower update: last week I sent this letter to the Texas Historical Commission. Since that time I also met with Judge Criner to make sure we are on the same page, and we are. I encourage folks to reach out to her, Mayor Stewart and the THC to stop this construction. 765 kV update: This is a little bit of inside baseball analysis, but don't forget that the Chief ALJ at the State Office of Administrative Hearings, Kristofer Monson, is a gubernatorial appointee. With the election of Gov. Elect Hinojosa AND the timing such that the ALJ has yet to issue the remand opinion in the 59475 case, you can be certain that these cases are on the radar of Gov. Hinojosa's transition team. Put another way, as independent as it would otherwise appear, SOAH will still bend to the pressure of the incoming Governor or ... risk some major shakeup in this next legislative session. The 59475 remand opinion, if it is ever issued, will be written with new leadership in mind. Stormwater flooding from IC ISD campus: I met with Supt. Heath last week and reminded him that Gallagher, the construction manager for the 2024 bonds, has yet to remedy the stormwater flooding from the new transportation facility that runs into the alley immediately north of the tennis courts. I continue to maintain that the City should not transfer 3rd street pursuant to the MOU between the District and the City until the District successfully directs that water east down the alley into the new flood detention area. Gallagher and the District have known since day one that the water had to be re-redirected in order to prevent flooding of private property. The leverage the City has, of course, is to not give up 3rd Street, and it is very good leverage since they own and control the alley. Lange permit request at the Irion County Water Conservation Board: My understanding is that Board staff is gathering data to better understand how the proposed permits will impact the aquifer. Once that information is known it will then be time for the City and private landowners to evaluate whether they have legal standing under the Board's rules. More on that later. Pending Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Irion County ISD November 11 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting The new cell tower going in at 3rd and Main in Mertzon is an eyesore. Whether it is being lawfully constructed is to be determined. In the background is the Irion County Courthouse. See my update in the Commentary below. A. Agenda Analysis Here are the meeting documents for this meeting: Minutes from last meeting Check Register Revenue English as a Second Language Report 1909 Building Bid w Option A Construction update: I will be listening to see if the folks at Gallagher and Parkhill have designed and constructed the windrow down the alley east of the new transportation facility, as the promised the City of Mertzon they would do. Consent agenda: Unless a board member "pulls" an item from the agenda, there will be a quick vote approving the minutes from the last meeting, check register and revenue statement. See the linked items above. I've uploaded the check register for analysis by AI, and you can read that at the bottom of this page. Revenue: Because this is the period the District has no income until folks start paying their year end property taxes for 2026, I thought it would be interesting to run the revenue report through AI. Here is the result: Revenue Realization Analysis Total realized revenue sits at $85,964.22 (0.52% of the $16.42M annual target): Property Taxes (Object 5710): Realized collections in September were just $4,503.43 (M&O) and $1,415.70 (I&S) against a combined $14.66M tax levy budget. Tax statements are typically mailed in October, with over 80% of revenue arriving between December and February. State Foundation & Other State Revenue (Objects 5810, 5830): The district received $15,896.00 in Per Capita/Foundation funding and $26,184.86 from other state agencies, totaling $42,080.86 (7.16% realized). Cafeteria Operations (Fund 240): Collected $2,690.30 in local food sales (4.89%) and $5,965.51 in federal meal reimbursements (6.28%) against the $270,000 self-balancing budget. Key Financial Anomalies & Observations State Recapture Dominates Budget (43.53% of Fund 199): $5,415,200.00 is budgeted under Function 91 for Chapter 49 recapture payments to the state. While $0 had been paid as of September 30, the October check register shows the district executed its final prior-year settlement of $234,841.00 on October 14. Accelerated Spending in Security & Monitoring (Function 52): Function 52 has expended $34,077.16 of its $64,583.00 budget in Month 1 (52.76% spent). In particular, security payroll (6100) sits at $34,077.16 expended against a $35,908.00 line budget (94.90% expended). This suggests an upfront annual SRO interlocal agreement or upfront officer compensation that requires a budget amendment. High Co-Curricular Fall Outlays (Function 36): Extracurricular activities expended $75,806.27 (15.77%) in September alone, driven by fall sports kickoff, travel, equipment purchases, and game-day operational costs. Front-Loaded Mandated Assessments (Functions 93 & 99): Appraisal District (Function 99): Paid $61,609.53 (24.64% of budget), reflecting Irion County Appraisal District's quarterly billing cycle. Special Education Co-op (Function 93): Disbursed $41,636.68 (22.51% of budget) for the district's fall contribution to the Menard Special Education Cooperative. Accounting Adjustment in Health Services (Function 33): Function 33 shows a negative expenditure of -$755.40 (Payroll Costs 6100), indicating a payroll accrual reversal, inter-fund reclassification, or prior-year adjustment. 5. Audit report, Item 8.1: Typically the District has one of its auditors give a report of their findings. This item is among the most important for the entire year. 6. FFA presentation. The FFA students practice for their oral advocacy competition before the board. Always worthwhile. The cupola at the legacy IC ISD 1909 building can be seen in the background. The 199 foot tall tower eclipses the 2 story building, and it is easily now the tallest object in the entire city. An emergency services helipad is only two blocks to the east of the tower. I will report back on my PIA request to the Texas Historical Commission when I have those documents. B. Meeting Review Audit report, Item 8.1: The Board approved its annual audit report. Here is the audit report and some AI analysis. The starting point is the fund balance, which this year is down $66,000 to $7.9 million. Long term debt is down from $35.9 million to $32 million. Revenues are down from $22 million to $21.7 million, expenses are down ("slightly" though the numbers were audible at the meeting), and "profit" was $3.2 million. Construction update: no one was present from either Gallagher or Parkhill. From the rapid pace of construction - and Gallagher’s continued inaction on the windrow for the alley to redirect the transportation facility stormwater - it is transparent that they are rushing to get on down the road to their next job. It’s like I said during the 2019 build out: these design and construction companies are after one thing - our county’s mineral wealth. Gallagher and Parkhill promised the moon and stars before the bond election, but now… C. Commentary Cell Tower update: I sent this letter to the Texas Historical Commission this week asking them to rescind their approval. The THC failed to receive accurate information about how the cell tower would destroy the viewshed of a historic building, the 1909 Mertzon Central School building on the IC ISD campus. If you can see the cell tower from your property, you too can ask the THC to rescind their approval. Reach out to me. Education sea change: A former school board president at Austin ISD, Gina Hinojosa, is now our Governor Elect, and she is promising major changes at TEA. I am hopeful for the repeal of school vouchers and anti DEI policies, issues I have railed against elsewhere in this blog. (Hinojosa, indeed, has called the voucher program a "scam".) There are also early promises on a new school finance system, though how that will be accomplished hasn't been made clear and litigation and appeals up to the Texas S. Court could take years. Watch also for changes in prayer in school laws and policies. 765 kV update: Lt. Gov. Patrick has been replaced by Lt. Gov. elect Goodwin, which represents yet another sea change. Currently pending are a PFD in the 59475 case and the Interim Charge Report out of the Senate Business and Commerce Committee. There wasn't a deadline set for the PFD issuance, and with Patrick walking out the door I doubt that a charge report will be published. On the other hand, the ALJ and the Committee may try to stake their ground before the change up in January. It seems more likely, though, that the status quo - silence - will continue. The PUC needs to take the bull by the horns and do what I have been recommending for months now: the PUC needs to withdraw its referrals to SOAH or file motions to dismiss in SOAH. All 5 cases need to expire. Even so, it should noted that on Nov 12 the PUC took no action on several motions for rehearing, which means some of the cases are ramping up for an appeal to District Court. More women in government: To date myself, I was a newly minted lawyer in the Consumer Protection Division, Lubbock Regional Office, at the Texas Attorney General's Office as Ann Richards was taking office as Governor of Texas in 1991. I have blogged previously about the need to have more women in leadership positions in government. Well, now we have it, with women serving as Texas Governor, Speaker of the House, Lt. Governor, Comptroller, and Chief Justice of the Texas Supreme Court. I'm looking forward to this. For starters, Gov. Elect Hinojosa is a graduate of the Plan II Honors Program at UT Austin. I relate. Check Register Analysis by AI: The top three payees account for $445,159.68, representing 82.13% of all district expenditures during October: Texas Education Agency (TEA) – $234,841.00 Check 101426 issued October 14, 2026, coded to Function 91 (Contracted Instructional Services Between Schools) for the final 2025–2026 recapture payment ("Robin Hood"). TASB Risk Management Fund – $168,682.00 Check 100126 covering district-wide annual liability and property coverages: Property Insurance: $142,213.00 Auto Comprehensive & Collision: $8,811.00 ($6,073.00 + $2,738.00) Data Breach & Privacy Liability: $5,500.00 School Liability Insurance: $5,320.00 Auto Liability: $4,838.00 Unemployment Compensation: $2,000.00 Menard Special Education Cooperative – $41,636.68 Check 028817 for the district’s member contribution toward shared special education services (Function 93). Departmental & Operational Highlights Debt Service & Energy Performance: First Financial Bank ($13,262.88): Ideal Impact payment plan for district facility energy management. Facilities & Utilities: City of Mertzon ($4,800.13): Water and sewer utilities. TXU Energy ($2,243.06): Campus electric bill. Carpet Tech ($3,234.49): Commercial carpet cleaning services. San-Tex Services ($1,750.00): HVAC filter replacements. Anthony Mechanical ($1,307.00): Hornet Gym A/C servicing. Transportation & Fuel: Kendrick Oil Company ($6,866.47): Bulk fuel split between student transportation ($3,228.67), athletics ($3,394.80), and maintenance ($243.00). Roberts Truck Center ($2,018.88): Repairs and maintenance on Bus #5. Child Nutrition Program (Fund 240): Core suppliers include Labatt Food Service ($5,769.06 across groceries and non-food supplies), Gandy's Dairies ($1,923.65), and A+ Fabrication ($1,339.05 for cafeteria cooler repairs). Extracurricular & Instructional: Hudl, Inc. ($7,199.00): Athletic video/analytics software subscription. Jonathan Derk Alvin ($2,500.00): Marching band drill design. BSN Sports ($2,477.55 combined): Athletic supplies and uniforms across checks 028806, 028827, 028844, and 028857. Professional Fees & Administration: Eichelbaum Wardell PC ($3,750.00): Two semi-monthly legal retainer payments of $1,875.00 each (checks 028845 and 028872). Education Service Center Region 15 ($1,100.00): Contracted bank reconciliation services across two installments. TASB, Inc. ($2,000.00): Annual BoardBook subscription for school board operations. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Irion County Water Conservation District November 9 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting My experience fighting the 765 kV transmission lines has convinced me that citizens and landowners must be more proactive about protecting the natural environment. That includes protecting underground water. A. Agenda Analysis Industrial Water Use Permit Request, Items 5-8: This is a request by Mr. Lange for 4 separate permits for 688 acre feet of water each. That is the equivalent of 2,752 acre feet of water per year, or 896.7 million gallons of water per year. That's a lot of water! Location: I first saw this posting on Facebook's Irion County News. That post raised immediate concerns because, according to the Texas Water Development Board, the water use for the entire City of Mertzon typically runs 110 to 140 acre feet per year, or 35.8 million to 45.6 million gallons per year. There's no way the City could withstand such a drawdown if the permit location is in or adjacent to Mertzon. But, the agenda gives a specific location for the permit: Abstract 1016, Section 18, Block 27, H&TC RR CO Survey. Using the Railroad Commission's GIS map, I came up with a location 10+ miles away from the City of Mertzon. Here are screenshots of the location according to the RRC: If I am incorrect about this location, please reach out to me. Also, see my Commentary below. The view of Spring Creek from the bridge at Brim's in Mertzon. B. Meeting Review Here is the audio for the public comments and the decision of the Board. Basically, the Board decided to move this to a formal hearing under the statute and rules. This will give those with legal standing more procedural and substantive due process rights than was provided at this hearing. I will be providing more information about that process in the near future. Note that during the reading of submitted comments it was noted that two neighbors were requesting a contested case hearing. So, this matter has ramped up to a dispute quickly. Who can protest at the next hearing? See page 27 of the District's rules. The general idea for the next stage is that only those persons who have a justiciable interest (legal injury) can become interested parties. Exactly how many folks might be in this category I would say is unknown at this point. Certainly adjacent and neighbors are going to likely meet the rule requirement, but beyond that is unclear It's also unclear to me just yet whether the two neighbors requested a contested case hearing are requesting the Board to do it or an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) to do it. Either are options under the rules. I anticipate covering the next public hearing on this site. C. Commentary Where ever the permit location, folks in Irion and Tom Green counties should be alarmed at the quantity of water proposed in these permits. At peak production of 896.7 million gallons of water production a year, these 4 permits compare to to the following data center annual use: Medium/Enterprise Facility: 110-180 million gallons per year; Large Hyperscale campus: 365 million to 1.1 billion gallons per year; and, Largest Mega Campuses: 1.0 to 1.8 billion gallons of water per year. If not for use by a data center, the water might aso be used to frac oil wells. A 10,000 foot lateral well uses approx. 30-50 acre feet of water. So, if limited to frac use, this water could be used to develop 60-90 wells per year. (Only 18 oil drilling permits have been approved by the Railroad Commission for Irion County in the last 3 months, but this might be a third party contract selling to oil companies for us across county lines.) To my many new readers, here is the short story of this site: The best way to describe this blog in its current state is that it is a civics experiment of a lawyer interested in getting folks engaged, in a civil manner, with their government. I don't make any money from the site, I don't endorse candidates, I have no staff...it is a labor of love of one person. I firmly believe that citizens need to exercise their 1st Amendment rights at public meetings as regularly as they possibly can to engage with their political leaders. The site was born, in fact, when a former Irion County ISD superintendent (unlawfully) called me out of order in an open meeting during my pubic comments to that board when I was protesting that IC ISD was flooding my residence with stormwater runoff and was about to make it worse with the construction of a new gym. My 1st Amendment rights concerning that dispute have been pasture raised, grass fed, in these pages, which has largely contributed to a much better relationship with Irion County ISD than before. Pending Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • 765 kV Documents

    Introduction | 59182 CCN Case | 59475 CCN Case | Commentary AI generated image of potential 765 kV line across West Texas. November 4, post election update: All of the Democrats who won, which includes all of the statewide offices, ran in opposition to data centers and the 765 kV lines. The 765 kV cases have lost their foundation. Here is another sign of the end: George Noelke is actively opposing and participating, pro se, as an intervenor in two (59182, which passes through Irion County and 59475 reaching Belton in Central Texas) of the proposed 765 kV line projects sought by Oncor and LCRA at the Texas Public Utility Commission. This page provides links to many of his legal documents that he filed, as well as other important documents. It is a work in process because the cases have yet to be decided finally by the PUC. The purported purpose of the lines was to provide additional electricity to the Permian Basin, which includes Irion County. As the cases unfolded, however, it became readily transparent that the lines would also be used as transmission lines for AI data centers. Landowners attacked whether the projects were needed; the lines were transmission lines and did not simultaneously provide for generation of additional electricity. And, as the cases neared final decision at the PUC, public outrage at data centers and the economics of mass energy generation have caused Governor Abbott to propose that data centers need to be responsible for their own energy generation. See additional commentary at the bottom of this page. A. 59182 (Involving Irion and other Texas Counties) October 7, 2026: Noelke’s Remand Brief in both 58182 and 59475 on two issues related to whether Oncor and LCRA have proven that the 765kV lines making up 59182 and 59475 are needed. I concluded they have not proven up need. Now pending: the ALJs will issue a remand PFD limited to the two issues with a period for party Exceptions and Replies to that PFD, and the Kennedy appeal before the Commissioners. September 30 and October 2: Oncor and LCRA respond to Kennedy’s appeal. Kennedy replies to their response. Note: this appeal applies to “Import Path 2” which is made up of both 59182 and 59475 cases. September 28, 2026: Scottish Rite Hospital (rocker b ranch in Irion County) filed their Motion to Confirm Applicability of Order 35 to 59182. The issue here is that 59182 Intervenors are being left out of the briefing on the consolidated "need" remand issues in 59475. The ALJ's ruled the same day with SOAH Order 28 and 36, providing that 59182 Intervenors have a right to brief the remand issues in 59475. This opens a can of worms, but I'll potentially address that later. September 23: Kevin Kennedy files his appeal to the PUC Commissoner's requesting an audit. September 22, 2026: Noelke's Objection and Motion to Strike Applicants’ Directory of Evidence. This is in response to Oncor/LCRA's filing a Directory of Evidence in both 59475 and 59182. The ALJs rule on my objection the same day with Order 35, providing that the parties in 59475 could brief the remand issues before the remand PFD was issued. (This was a partial victory, as I requested the same at Prayer paragraph 4 of my objection. But I also requested that both dockets, 59475 and 59182, be given briefing rights.) Note that Order 35 also provides that the ALJ's have no authority to require a audit and they deny his motion. September 10, 2026: Noelke’s Replies to Exceptions in 59475, with ongoing special appearance in 59182. This is undoubtedly tedious reading, but pay attention to: 1 the opening concerning the late breaking remand to SOAH, and 2, my summary on page 2 and 3. Here are Oncor/LCRA's Replies. Here is Commissioner Gleeson's proposed remand memo. (I provide a very brief response on the last page of my Replies at the Addendum.) September 2, 2026: Noelke's Exceptions in 59475 and Special Appearance in 59182. Filed in both 59182 and 59475, this document explains how the ALJ's in 59475 got it right. Here is what Oncor and LCRA filed to explain how the ALJ's got it wrong. The parties have 1 week to reply to one another. (This is being cross posted in 59182 and 59475 because the cases were consolidated on whether the 765 kV lines were "needed".) August 20, 2026: Proposal for Decision issued in 59475 against Oncor and LCRA. Since the decision on “need” was consolidated in 59182 and 59475, this means the “need” in 59182 likewise was not proven so 59182 now also falls. Caveat: the exceptions process has not been completed yet, and then the PUC has to issue its final agency order. August 19, 2026: Noelke’s Notice of Legislative Testimony in the Texas House State Affairs Committee. https://interchange.puc.texas.gov/search/documents/?controlNumber=59182&itemNumber=583 August 14, 2026: ALJ Exceptions Letter responding to Noelke’s jurisdiction issue filed, wholly rejecting his arguments. Noelkes exceptions not considered. (See Commentary below.) August 14, 2026: Go here to view the PUC board meeting addressing the 765 kV cases. PUCT Chairman Gleeson filed this memorandum about this meeting. Query whether the public comment by intervenors was ex parte. The same day Senator West files this letter on behalf of the Rocker B; note that he is not calling for dismissal of the cases. And, see the Exceptions Letter also filed the same day, mentioned above. August 2, 2026: Noelke's Notice of Legislative Testimony filed in 59182 and 59475. The PUC isn't as eager as Senator Schwertner is to get these cases dismissed, so this document serves as a prompt. July 31, 2026: Noelke’s jurisdiction objection to the PUC setting late deadlines (after the 180 days) for exceptions and replies to the PFD. July 29, 2026: Noelke’s testimony before the Texas Senate Business & Commerce Committee. July 15, 2026: Noelke’s Notice of Denial of CCN by Operation of Law. Note: about 1 day after filing this the PUC filed a response to the SOAH memorandum and set a deadline for exceptions and replies; See Item 555. Without briefing this here, this filing still does not adequately addressed the missed deadline; the PUC can't correct for the missed deadline simply by late filing their response. July 14, 2026: Applicants’ Reply to Motion to Dismiss July 7, 2026: Noelke’s Motion to Dismiss 59182 . (The pending deadline for the CCN to approved by the PUC is July 14, and it is legally impossible for them to meet that deadline. ) June 17, 2026: Noelke’s Exceptions to the PFD. June 9, 2026: Proposal For Decision (PFD) favoring Oncor/LCRA’s Route 228. April 10, 2026: Noelke’s Post Hearing Reply Brief with recommended Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Ordering provisions. April 3, 2026: Noelke’s Initial Post Hearing Brief. February 18, 2026: Noelke's Statement of Position and Route Adequacy Challenge and Direct Testimony. B. 59475 case (some postings here are identical and crossposted to 59182 posting above because the cases were consolidated on the "need" issue) October 7, 2026: Noelke’s Remand Brief in both 58182 and 59475 on two issues related to whether Oncor and LCRA have proven that the 765kV lines making up 59182 and 59475 are needed. He concluded they have not proven up need. Now pending: the ALJs will issue a remand PFD limited to the two issues with a period for party Exceptions and Replies to that PFD, and the Kennedy appeal before the Commissioners. September 28, 2026: Scottish Rite Hospital (rocker b ranch in Irion County) filed their Motion to Confirm Applicability of Order 35 to 59182. The issue here is that 59182 Intervenors are being left out of the briefing on the consolidated "need" remand issues in 59475. The ALJ's ruled the same day with SOAH Order 28 and 36, providing that 59182 Intervenors have a right to brief the remand issues in 59475. This opens a can of worms, but I'll potentially address that later. September 23: Kevin Kennedy files his appeal to the PUC Commissoner's requesting an audit. September 22, 2026: Noelke's Objection and Motion to Strike Applicants’ Directory of Evidence. This is in response to Oncor/LCRA's filing a Directory of Evidence in both 59475 and 59182. The ALJs rule on my objection the same day with Order 35, providing that the parties in 59475 could brief the remand issues before the remand PFD was issued. (This was a partial victory, as I requested the same at Prayer paragraph 4 of my objection. But I also requested that both dockets, 59475 and 59182, be given briefing rights.) Note that Order 35 also provides that the ALJ's have no authority to require a audit and they deny his motion. September 10, 2026: Noelke’s Replies to Exceptions in 59475, with ongoing special appearance in 59182. This is undoubtedly tedious reading, but pay attention to: 1 the opening concerning the late breaking remand to SOAH, and 2, my summary on page 2 and 3. Here are Oncor/LCRA's Replies. Here is Commissioner Gleeson's proposed remand memo. (I provide a very brief response on the last page of my Replies at the Addendum.) September 2, 2026: Noelke's Exceptions in 59475 and Special Appearance in 59182. Filed in both 59182 and 59475, this document explains how the ALJ's in 59475 got it right. Here is what Oncor and LCRA filed to explain how the ALJ's got it wrong. The parties have 1 week to reply to one another. (This is being cross posted in 59182 and 59475 because the cases were consolidated on whether the 765 kV lines were "needed".) August 20, 2026: Proposal for Decision issued in 59475 against Oncor and LCRA. Since the decision on “need” was consolidated in 59182 and 59475, this means the “need” in 59182 likewise was not proven so 59182 now also falls. Caveat: the exceptions process has not been completed yet, and then the PUC has to issue its final agency order. August 19, 2026: Noelke’s Notice of Legislative Testimony in the Texas House State Affairs Committee. https://interchange.puc.texas.gov/search/documents/?controlNumber=59475&itemNumber=6440 May 17 - July 29, 2026, en masse dismissal of Intervenor issue: Noelke's Objection to Applicants' List of Intervenors who did not file Statement of Position or Direct Testimony and Motion to Provide Notice and Opportunity for Hearing. And, Applicants' Response to Noelke . And, Another response by Noelke of the dismissal of over 800 Intervenors en masse. And, yet another Noelke Motion for Clarification of Order Dismissing 839 Intervenors en masse. Note: this list is incomplete. For a plain English summary of these arguments, see the third point here: testimony to the Senate Business and Commerce Committee on July 29. May 9, 2026 Noelke's Statement of Position. May 5, 2026 Noelke's Response to Applicants' Objection to Kennedy's Motion for Continuance. C. Commentary September 27, 2026: Gov. Abbott’s latest comments about the “pause” on data centers: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DdymLZ7CS1L/?stkn=NnU3ejdtbTZuYzVr September 21, 2026 update: A very technical remand related to the issue of whether the line currently proposed through Irion County is needed has been filed by the PUC. The PUC appears to be siding with Oncor and LCRA that the ALJs were wrong in the PFD that recommended a denial of the line because it was not needed. My strategy is developing. I am waiting to see what the revised PFD recommends. In the meantime, read this article from the Texas Scorecard. A reader asked me after the Senate Business and Commerce Committee came out recommending denial of the 765 kV applications whether the PUC had to follow the Senate committee's wishes. My answer is, no, but if they don't they will see their appropriations from the legislature decrease the next session. Those dominoes are starting to fall, because it is becoming increasingly transparent that the PUC and ERCOT do not wish to follow the Senate committee's (and the Lt. Gov.'s) recommendation. To understand the pressure being applied in the background the missing piece is that the PUC Commissioners must approve and pay the salary and contract of the ERCOT CEO. In other words, the PUC is being placed in a position of challenging the Lt. Gov., who has lost confidence in ERCOT. Watch for the pressure to be increased as we near the session, only 4 months away. And, keep in mind, the Senate's interim charge report on the 765 kV's has yet to be completed. As reported by the Texas Scorecard, the ERCOT CEO is proposed to receive $4.4 million next year. September 3, 2026: The law is such that it is extremely difficult for an agency to change certain Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in a PFD, Proposal for Decision. Applicants' Exceptions, though, just as well have the kitchen sink in it, so this may well be a situation where the Commission makes substantive changes to the PFD. August 22, 2026: Here is the entire PFD in 59475 favoring the landowners. Here are some key things to know: a. The dates for exceptions and replies to exceptions can be found here. The ALJ's have until September 15 to finalize the PFD. As of the date of this posting, no date has been set for the oral argument for this pfd or for the 59182 PFD. b. Here is the law on what the PUC can do if they seek to change the PFD and the ALJ's final corrections in any way: 1. 16 TAC 22.262 & 2. Texas Gov't Code 2001.058(e). My take away: It is going to be extremely difficult for the PUC to change the lynchpin, Conclusion of Law # 13, which reads, ERCOT’s PBRP recommendation is not entitled to great weight in the determination of need for this reliability project." The Applicants relied solely on the Permian Basin Reliability Project to justify the 765 kV lines, and if it isn't given great weight, then the PFD will stand. August 16, 2026: This Exceptions Letter says I am headed to Oral Argument at the PUC. Note: losses down below in the administrative process creates more grounds for appeal at the district court and above process. Will update site once the PUC announces when oral argument is scheduled. July 31, 2026: A couple things come to mind after attending the full day (14 hour) Senate Business and Commerce Committee in Austin on July 29: HB 5066 was initially understood to be a "study" bill, not the justification for using the Permian Basin Reliability Plan to build 765 kV lines. The 180 day deadline is already understood to be be too aggressive by both the PUC and this Committee. The en masse dismissal of the 839 Intervenors in 59475 is weighing heavy on the minds of the Committee members. Here is my written testimony to the Committee. My spoken testimony was much more brief because speakers were only allowed two minutes. The day after this hearing I filed this notice about the PUC's and SOAH's ongoing lack of jurisdiction. July 4, 2026: Bruce Springsteen recently said in this interview, "Well, I believe in critical patriotism. I believe that's the definition of a patriot, that you love your country so much that you are willing to look at it clearly, recognize its faults, encourage it to be a better place, and believe that you carry in your heart the country that is waiting." There's no better example of critical patriotism than the massive numbers of landowners who have come out to fight these 765 kV projects. These are the folks who understand how unjust this process has been, not the elected legislators and the Governor who have come late to the process to register their misgivings. Elsewhere in these pages I have quoted James Baldwin, "I love America more than any other country in the world and, exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to criticize her perpetually.” These are the things I am thinking about on this 250th celebration. June 20, 2026: Listen to this February 2026 interview of Elon Musk for why he thinks in 30-36 months AI data centers will be located in space. It comes down to 1) it is very difficult to build large scale energy generation plants on the ground, and 2) solar energy in space. Keep in mind that these 765 kV projects are transmission not generation projects. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Mertzon City Council November 2 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting The cell tower being constructed at 3rd and Main is already an eyesore, and the process undertaken by its consultant and owner to get it approved is nothing short of a travesty. See photos and commentary below. A. Agenda Analysis 391, Item 5: This item will address the appointment to the 391 Commission approved last week by the City. Irion County ISD can be seen in the background and is only two blocks away. B. Meeting Review This meeting was cancelled for lack of a quorum. Watch for these agenda items to be on the next meeting agenda, which will like be on November 16. I am leaving this page in place for the commentary below. I called Ms. Kampman on October 22, 2026, and she said that because Judge Criner did not say in her letter below that she wished to be considered a "consulting party", they did not treat her as one. It was bad faith on the part of Tri Leaf to interpret Judge Criner's letter above that she did not wish to be a "consulting party". Ms. Kampman, however, told me that Judge Criner was not treated as a "consulting party" because she did not explicitly say so in her letter. C. Commentary Cell tower: This is a developing dispute. I initially requested a copy of the Texas Historical Commission concurrence letter approving the site in my phone call with Ms. Kampman. In an email on Oct. 28, 2026, Ms. Kampman advised that since their case was closed, she couldn't give it to me (?!) but she could give me the file number at THC, 202608771. On October 30, I sent an open records request to the Texas Historical Commission for some information that I hope to publish in the near future. I am also aware that both Dr. Joyce Gray with the Irion County Historical Commission and Judge Criner with Irion County have also been in touch with the Texas Historical Commission. I will provide updates as I have them. As of November 3, construction is ongoing. Here is the status: 765 kV update: Local Meredith McCall uploaded this article, Texas Officals huddled with Tech Companies before grid blitz, on the Interchange for all the 765 cases on October 28. I urge you to read it, especially if you haven't yet voted. The bottom line is that rural Texas is being betrayed by state leadership in Austin. Another 765 kV update: I recommend this Texas Monthly article published on October 27: A Billionaire GOP Donor’s Ranch Was in the Path of Proposed Transmission Lines. Then It Wasn’t. Regrettably, once you are in the trenches fighting this fight it is easier to identify the injustices of the route selection. The Irion County Courthouse can be seen in the background. Photo taken on October 28, 2026. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Mertzon City Council October 19 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting Window Rock, Big Bend National Park. A recent victory that stops the border wall and road building in the park is being appealed by the Trump administration. It is a grave injustice to destroy the beauty of this park in the name of border security. Here is the order being appealed that stops the construction. A. Agenda Analysis 391 MOU with Irion County, Item 7: There are a number of very important issues on this agenda, but this one addresses the potential to stop the 765 kV and data center construction county wide. Here's some background on what they are and the process of forming them. Wastewater Bid, Item 11: It has taken a long while to get here, but, all that aside, this is for much needed upgrades to the municipal wastewater plant. 20.03 Ordinance, item 9: This addresses how to count and bill for water usage at RV parks, a matter not resolved at the previous meeting. Tax roll, item 6: This will be to approved the final, final tax roll. Local Newspaper, Item 5: State law requires the publication of municipal public notices in a local newspaper. What happens if the town doesn't have one? Electricity contract, Item 8: Why pay attention to municipal electricity contracts? The costs of energy use for everyone, including municipal users, will go up with the development of 765 kV lines and data centers throughout the state. Duck hunting in the Maurepas Swamp Wildlife Management Area, northwest of New Orleans. The swamp yielded no Yellow Bellied Whistlers, but every hunt is a good hunt is my philosophy. B. Meeting Review Here are the meeting documents. 391 creation, Item 7: The Council unanimously voted to approve the 391 Commission with Irion County. See p 5 of the meeting documents. This is significant victory. Special recognition here goes to Mayor Stewart, who voiced his opinions favoring the Commission during this meeting, and Carla Lindley, the At Large representative on the County's side who helped shepherd this through with the County and made the presentation at this meeting. 2026 Tax Roll, Item 6: The Council approved the tax roll. The significance is that it verifies the City's portion of the overall tax revenue for the tax rate they approved. See pages 3 and 4 of the meeting documents, which are valuable for also showing the cut for the other taxing entities. If my math is correct, out of the grand total of $28,257,013 being collected for all taxing authorities, the City of Mertzon will get $308,486. Wastewater bid approval, Item 11: The Council approved the Texas Water and Soil bid of $1,525,632 recommended by Hibbs & Todd. Once the Texas Water Development Board gives its final approval, the project should be completed within 300-330 days. See meeting documents at 13. Local newspaper, Item 5: The Council renewed their approval of The Big Lake Wildcat as the "local" paper for public notices. Travis' Letter from the Alamo was installed this month at the Irion County Courthouse. Here's more about the Travis Letter. C. Commentary Alley update: See my Commentary at No. 1 here regarding the design of the new IC ISD transportation facility and its stormwater distribution design to dump stormwater directly into the alley at between 4th and 5th streets in Mertzon. The City should not transfer 3rd Street to IC ISD under the MOU until plans are disclosed and construction is complete on a solution to direct this stormwater into the new stormwater development pond nearby. Gallagher Construction and Parkhill need to be better corporate citizens in our community than to design facilities that flood our alleys, streets and property owners. New cell tower location at 3rd and Main, Mertzon: The new 391 Commission should take action to stop this construction. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Irion County ISD October 14 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting Monarch Butterflies stop by Mertzon each October on their way to Mexico for the winter. One of their locations is on public property, and if you'll reach out to me I'll let you in on their rest stop. Photograph Copyright 2026 G Noelke October 14, 2026 at 6:00 PM - Board Meeting Agenda 1. Call to Order Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 2. Opening Ceremonies Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 3. Student Recognitions Speaker(s): Dr. Jessica Parker 4. Public Comments Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 5. Construction Update Speaker(s): Gallagher Construction 6. Consent Agenda Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 7. Administration Reports Speaker(s): Dr. Jessica Parker, Dr. Michael Heath, John Morrow, Ben Martin Description: 1. Dr. Jessica Parker (Principal Update) 2. Coach John Morrow (Athletics Update) 3. Ben Martin (Band Update) 4. Dr. Michael Heath (Superintendent Update) 8. Action Items Speaker(s): Dr. Michael Heath, Alexis Jackson, Gallagher Construction Description: 1. Discuss/Approve ESL Program Evaluation (Presented by Mrs. Jackson) 2. Discuss/Approve FLETCO to handle the renovations of the 1909 building. 3. Report on board member training hours (No Action) 9. Executive Session Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 10. Return to Open Session Speaker(s): Chad Koonce 11. Adjournment Speaker(s): Chad Koonce A. Agenda Analysis Location: the school cafeteria at the intersection of Juanita and 4th. Formatting: I'm still working out the formatting and documents production since the District has moved to Boardbook. English as a Second Language (ESL), item 8.1: If I am reading the data correct, the District receives only $649.00 in federal grants for 26-27. See TEA's Entitlement and Allocation Dashboards. The current Dept. of Education proposed budget for Title III funds zero's out roughly $890 million nationally for these grants. The federal law mandating that programs be provided, however, has not been repealed by Congress. FLETCO bid approval to renovate the 1909 building, item 8.2: Once the 2024 bond monies are spent on this part of the bond build out, for the first time since 1909 this building will be dedicated to Administration only. Or, that's the plan. If the District has a growth spurt, the former classrooms in this building may become valuable as classrooms again. In any event, this contract is worth $2.6 million, according a site skimming data from the Texas Dept. of Licensing and Registration. (Time permitting, I'll go back and find original source data here.) Pay attention to this construction because not just any firm can do it - the building is recognized as historical, so their are certain legal limitations, at least on the exterior. (In my day there, it contained the school cafeteria.) Pending - if I get access to meeting docs in advance to the meeting I will post them. Still working out the bugs with Boardbook. Monarch Butterfly in Mertzon, Copyright 2026 G Noelke B. Meeting Review Approve Fletco bid to renovate 1909 building, item 8.2: The Board approved a $6,371,854 bid to approve renovations to the 1909 legacy building. Here is the approved bid package. I asked Gemini for some analysis: Here is a summary of the project expense categories for the Irion County ISD 1909 Building Renovation: • Construction Costs / Cost of Work: $5,171,524 ◦ Combination Proposal (Fletco Construction, LP): $3,986,300 ◦ Owner Allowances & Systems Estimates: $409,000 total (covering Roofing, Fire Sprinklers, Voice/Data Cabling, Audio Visual, Communication, Fire Alarm, Security Access, Video Cameras, and Intrusion Detection) ◦ Site & Project Support Line Items: $37,900 (includes subsurface investigation, storage trailers, SWPPP inspections, moisture testing, shipping, printing, and builder's risk insurance) ◦ Construction Contingency: $400,000 ◦ Construction Management Fee & General Requirements (Cumming Gallagher): $338,324 • Fees and Owner's Direct Expenses: $476,830 ◦ Architectural & Engineering Fees (Parkhill Architects): $399,330 total across interior, exterior, and civil engineering ◦ Testing, Inspections, & Commissioning: $63,000 total (Material Testing/Inspection by eHT, HVAC Test & Balance and MEP Commissioning by Campos Engineering) ◦ Permits & Accessibility Reviews: $17,500 total (Building Permit/Plan Review/Inspections and TAS Reviews) • Furniture, Fixtures, & Equipment (FF&E): $400,000 ◦ FF&E Allowance Estimate: $400,000 • Miscellaneous Contingencies: $323,500 ◦ Owner Move-In Estimate: $75,000 ◦ Utility & Technology Allowances: $95,000 total ($15,000 Gas/Electric; $80,000 Technology) ◦ Asbestos/Hazardous Materials Survey (King Consultants): $3,500 ◦ Owner Contingency: $150,000 Consent agenda, expenses, item 6: The Board approved expenses for the previous month, and here is the check register. Here is a Gemini summary: This document is a Year-to-Date Check Register for Irion County ISD covering the period from September 1, 2026, to September 30, 2026 (Accounting Period: A, Run Date: October 9, 2026). Financial Overview Grand Total Disbursed: $265,360.19 across 4 pages of transactions. Payment Methods: All listed payments were issued as checks/direct disbursements (EFT flagged as "N"). Largest Expenditures Irion County Appraisal District: $61,609.53 (Check 028716) for the 4th-quarter apportionment. Sonora ISD: $21,625.00 (Check 028796) for Educational Life Skills. Fairview Accelerated: $20,164.42 (Check 028736) for a fair share agreement. The Brokerage Store: $18,960.00 (Check 028729) for student insurance. TXU Energy: $18,328.50 (Check 028798) for district electricity. TASB RMF: $17,349.00 (Check 090126) for quarterly workers' compensation insurance split across instructional, maintenance, and cafeteria funds. Arbiter Pay: $10,000.00 (Check 090726) for athletic game officials. First Financial Bank: $9,170.10 (Check 028713) for an Ideal Impact payment plan. Key Expenditure Categories Instructional & Digital Curricula: Edmentum district-wide license ($5,858.00), Lowman Education renewal ($1,650.00), Lead4ward ($1,500.00 total), Amplify Education ($776.25), and Frontline Technologies ($635.00). Athletics & Extracurriculars: Band props from Band Today ($2,071.00), Tarpley Music repairs ($3,183.73), football coach headsets from Porta Phone ($3,499.26), Perry Weather service ($4,284.00), Glasscock Co. ISD District 11-A fees ($5,000.00), UIL membership ($2,500.00), and drug testing ($2,796.00). Operations, Utilities & Facilities: City of Mertzon water/sewer ($4,688.90), Kendrick Oil fuel ($4,399.76), Mayfield Paper custodial supplies ($4,359.98 across three orders), Thyssenkrupp elevator quarterly service ($2,027.14), and Roberts Truck Center bus repairs ($2,094.85). Internal VISA Accounts: Routine departmental credit card statements cleared on September 24, including Administration ($535.32), Athletics ($680.18 net of an AT&T credit), Band ($1,959.30), Elementary ($35.00), and Maintenance ($949.15). Pending Monarch Butterfly in Mertzon, Copyright 2026 G Noelke C. Commentary 2024 IC ISD Bond update: After this meeting, I visited in the parking lot with two Gallagher representatives about the stormwater runoff from the new transportation facility that was designed by Parkhill to purposefully dump into a City of Mertzon alley. Gallagher and Parkhill have taken the exact same approach with our community's 2024 school bond funds that architect Jeffrey Potter and WBK Construction took with the construction of City Gym in 2019. They are by design dumping stormwater runoff into a public right of way and looking the other way as property owners and the City of Mertzon get flooded. I'll change my opinion on this when I see the design plans, which I have previously requested many times, that direct the stormwater coming off the transportation facility into the new stormwater detention area nearby. Gallagher and Parkhill need to be better corporate citizens and stop intentionally flooding local government and property owners. 765 kV update: We are in a holding pattern for the line proposed thru Irion County, as well as the line east that goes from Eldorado to Belton. You can find my latest filings over at my 765 kV Documents page. We had a briefing deadline last week for two very specific remanded issues related to whether Oncor and LCRA had proven up that they needed the line. The Administrative Law Judges must now write an amended Proposal for Decision, and then there's yet another briefing period where the Intervenors get to take issue with that decision. And, after that, it has to be scheduled for public meeting for oral argument and decision by the PUC Commissioners. There is also a separate appeal to the PUC Commissioners, the Kennedy appeal, that has yet to be decided. For those in favor of stalling the case until the next legislative session starts in January, my guess is they will get their wish. Also, keep in mind the Texas Senate Business and Commerce Committee has an interim charge to report on, so before long (but probably not before the mid term elections) we should have some legislative recommendations. I have a habit of reviewing the IC ISD bidding documents over at the Gallgher website. I recently found this gem buried deep in one of the documents: I don't think this data is entirely accurate...the rain storms are intensifying. And, street flooding around Mertzon happens even at 1" of rain. In any event, I'm going to continue to pay my flood insurance premium, especially in light of my comments at 1 above. 4. I am simultaneously dealing with three eminent domain matters (Matterhorn pipeline, Eiger pipeline and Oncor/LCRA 765 kV transmission line) and one inverse condemnation matter (Irion County ISD). Were I not a lawyer able to represent myself, my legal bills would be through the roof. Our state legislature, Governor, Lt. Governor and local government are not property owner friendly. The next time you hear about what a great place Texas is and how business friendly it is, factor this in: the rural landscape is being raped. 5. Pending Monarch Butterfly in Mertzon, Copyright 2026 G Noelke Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Irion County ISD September 29 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting The McDonald Observatory at Fort Davis is only 238 miles west of Mertzon. BoardBook agenda for this meeting. A. Agenda Analysis Time: Note the time of this meeting is at 7:30 am. There's no requirement in the Texas Open Meeting Act addressing what time is a lawful time. This Board always meets around 6:00 pm. Can they meet early? Yes. The law provides that meetings only have to be "open to the public". (Texas Gov't Code 551.002.) A meeting at 7:30 is generally no less accessible than one around 6:00 pm. Contrast that with a meeting at, say, 4:00 am. An argument might be made that meeting was inaccessible to the public because of its unusual time, and therefore it would not be "open to the public". Approve the tax roll, Item 3 a. : This is the final tax roll that should firmly determine the District's income next year from 2026 taxes. I'm unsure why this wasn't approved before Aug 31; I recall there is a good reason, I just don't remember it. DIP and CIP, items 3b and c: I had to reach out to Supt. Heath to decode these. These are the "District Improvement Plan" and "Campus Improvement Plan". Each year there are modifications to the TEA required plans. Here is the 24-25 District Improvement Plan, for example. If you go to a "star party" at the Observatory you don't get to see space from their largest telescope at the top of the mountain (the 2nd largest telescope in the world), but you do get a chance to view from telescopes like the one in the lower right. B. Meeting Review Meeting documents - I will post them in the near future. Tax Roll, item 3A: The Board approved the tax roll. District and Campus improvement plans, items 3B & C: After a few brief comments from Supt. Heath, the Board approved. The Cactus Museum at the Chihuahuan Desert Research Center near Fort Davis is worth the trip. C. Commentary Meeting location: I was in such a hurry on this page I didn't realize that I had not posted the location. The meeting was at Duke's Mercantile and Coffee (Facebook), no doubt a show of support by the Board for their former member, Ashley Hill, who owns and runs the place. Can public meetings be held at private businesses like this? Yes, meetings have to be generally accessible to the public, and this one definitely was. She brews a good drip, and there's ample half and half in a side fridge. I recommend it. 103 N. Broadway, Mertzon, Texas 76941. NYT article: 30 Ideas for Fixing US Schools, Ranked by Experts. Advocacy tip: When you don't understand the language being used in a public meeting agenda (like CIP and DIP), just reach out to the governmental body and ask for an interpretation. Links: McDonald Observatory, Chihuahuan Desert Nature Center. Here's an example of a star cluster, the Wild Duck Star Cluster, that you can see while at the Observatory at one of their Star Parties. We stayed at a nearby AirBnB, but another option for lodging that is in the mountains and quite close to the Observatory is The Prude Ranch. I also recommend the horseback rides at the ranch. What you aren't seeing on Government in the Sun: political endorsements and race analysis. Again, this is more of an experiment in civics than a political or news site. My exception will be evaluating how politics have impacted the 765 kV line cases. Stay tuned for that over on my 765 kV page at the Commentary section. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Mertzon City Council September 21 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting Mural on the J.M. Carson building, downtown Mertzon, circa 2016. A. Agenda Analysis Ordinance 20.03, item 5: This item appear last week with an incorrect citation to Ordinance 20.02. Here is the current (March 2025) version of 20.03. The Council heard from business owner Jayton Lindley last week but failed to take action because of the incorrect citation. Mr. Lindley owns an trailer park and is requesting the Council to re-evaluate how it counts water meters at RV parks. This could open up additional water meters in the City. See my commentary below. B. Meeting Review Here are the meeting documents. Though no formal vote was taken regarding Ordinance 20.03 relating to how water meters are counted at trailer parks, this was an excellent meeting. The Counsel spent more than an hour deliberating with Jayton Lindley on the issue, and the discussion wasn't always easy to follow. The deliberative process in an open meeting often can't be precise or linear; sometimes it takes multiple discussions. The Council will be receiving more information at its next meeting on this issue. More on Robert's Rules: I always pay attention if there is a motion on the table and whether it is seconded. During this meeting, a council member stated an motion, without the call of the Mayor, and immediately the motion was discussed, and discouraged, before a second for the motion was ever made. When all members are cordial and getting along, this is a fine approach. If there is motion on the table when folks aren't getting along, sparks might fly. As I understand Robert's, one way to formally "kill" a motion is for the Chair to ask for a second. If there is no second, the motion dies on the spot. If there IS a second, then it has to be voted upon. This method prevents there from being multiple motions on the table at the same time. If board members aren't getting along or have don't share the same opinion on the wording of a motion, the rules on how to dispose of competing motions become more important. C. Commentary Accuracy matters in posted agenda items. This agenda is an excellent example of how careful governmental bodies have to be when drafting agendas. Last week it was announced during the meeting that the citation to the ordinance was incorrect. The proper course of action, as was done here, was to repost for the following meeting with the correct posting. The Council was barred from taking action under the incorrect agenda item. "Taking action" typically means voting, so the Council last meeting could not have voted on an incorrectly cited ordinance. They did hear from Mr. Lindley last meeting, though, as he was permitted to speak. No action was taken then, and no discussion was had about his comments. 765 kV update: A very technical remand related to the issue of whether the line currently proposed through Irion County is needed has been filed by the PUC. The PUC appears to be siding with Oncor and LCRA that the ALJs were wrong in the PFD that recommended a denial of the line because it was not needed. My strategy is developing. I am waiting to see what the revised PFD recommends. In the meantime, read this article from the Texas Scorecard. A reader asked me after the Senate Business and Commerce Committee came out recommending denial of the 765 kV applications whether the PUC had to follow the Senate committee's wishes. My answer is, no, but if they don't they will see their appropriations from the legislature decrease this next session. Those dominoes are starting to fall, because it is becoming increasingly transparent that the PUC and ERCOT do not wish to follow the Senate committee's (and the Lt. Gov.'s) recommendation. To understand the pressure being applied in the background the missing piece is that the PUC Commissioners must approve and pay the salary and contract of the ERCOT CEO. In other words, the PUC is being placed in a position of challenging the Lt. Gov., who has lost confidence in ERCOT. Watch for the pressure to be increased as we near the session, only 4 months away. And, keep in mind, the Senate's interim charge report on the 765 kV's has yet to be completed. As reported by the Texas Scorecard, the ERCOT CEO is proposed to receive $4.4 million next year. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • IC ISD Board Meeting September 14 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting IC ISD campus under construction the week before this meeting. A. Agenda Analysis BoardBook: The Board has recently started using BoardBook, a web based meeting preparation software. This is a really positive development that I'll be pointing out here and there. The agenda above is a screen shot of how it looks on BoardBook. When I find out who to send your request to to get subscribed, I will post it here. Meeting documents - Here are the meeting documents for this meeting. (Amazing!) SB 12, Item 4: This is the new DEI policy required by state law. Another example of the benefits of BoardBook...read the policy before the meeting by reviewing the meeting documents at pages 2-5. I also provided some Commentary below on these policies. Consent agenda, item 6: At last, the mystery is gone. By reviewing the meeting documents in advance of the meeting, you can see exactly what they will be approving on the consent agenda. This includes meeting minutes for the last meeting, the revenue and expenses. Here is Google Gemini’s verbatim summary of the check register: “The check register for Irion County ISD, covering the period from Aug 01, 2026, to Aug 31, 2026, reflects a total expenditure of $78,478.97. The disbursements include operational costs, facility maintenance, and various staff and student activity expenses. Disbursement Summary • Facility Maintenance & Utilities: Significant payments were made for essential services, including $14,182.55 to TXU Energy for electricity and $4,362.21 to the City of Mertzon for water and sewer services. Maintenance projects featured a $4,750.00 heat pump installation by Bowles Heating & C and $3,237.88 for walk-in cooler service at the cafeteria. • Instructional & Administrative Support: The district invested $5,800.00 in tax collection services and $2,642.19 for the StopIt platform from Lightspeed Solutions. Additional costs included $1,510.86 for copier leasing from CTWP Leasing and $2,280.00 for CPR training provided by Sav-A-Life Skills. • Student Activities & Food Services: Substantial food service payments were made to Labatt Food Service ($5,471.02) and Gandy's Dairies ($1,309.12). Extracurricular expenses included $1,748.66 to BSN for football supplies and various smaller amounts for student athlete meals. • Security & Safety: Key safety expenditures included $2,945.84 to Raptor Technologies for a visitor management fee and $852.11 for a weather alerting package from Perry Weather. • Cancellations & Corrections: The register notes a $840.00 credit from Stadium Lanes due to a cancelled reservation. A $360.00 payment to Smashers for a staff outing was also voided and reposted to the correct period.” IC ISD construction the day of this meeting. This is northwest of the 1909 building, which is barely visible in the background. B. Meeting Review DEI compliance, item 4: The Board approved the policy. They had no choice. See my commentary below. This will do more harm than good. Administrative reports, Accountability, item 8: The Board accomplished a number of things at this meeting, but I want to highlight only one thing - the dramatic improvement in State accountability under Drs. Nikki Moore and Jessica Parker. IC ISD overall comparison '25 to '26. IC ISD high school comparison '25 to '26 IC ISD elementary comparison '25 to '26 IC ISD STAAR comparison to region and state. Green signifies exceeds, light orange signifies below. (Click on image to enlarge.) The entire accountability system is changing this year (again!), so it will be somewhat of an apples to oranges comparison under new Supt. Dr. Mike Heath. The improvement above is under Drs. Moore & Parker. (Note: I typically don't cover accountability on this site. Here's why: first, administrators, teachers and TEA know how to grade accountability on a curve, and, second, the goal posts are always changing. I am more interested in promoting the civic value that the community must expect constant improvement in public education, and a good way to achieve that is through community engagement at school board meetings. Regretfully, I was the only member of the public attending this meeting. All that said, there is some real importance in these numbers, and it’s worthwhile to point out the improvements.) C. Commentary Anti DEI Policy: See the policy at pages 3-5 here. I recognize that the Texas Legislature is forcing the District to pass this policy and so the District has no choice but to pass. I will be as plain spoken about this as I possibly can: History is not going to judge these policies favorably. They are racially discriminatory, misogynistic and most certainly violate the Equal Protection clauses of the Texas and U.S. Constitutions. Our federal government is showing its animus (spiteful or malevolent ill will) with this, removing disparate impact in Title VI regulations, while simultaneously dismantling the Office of Civil Rights within the Dept. of Education and moving it to other agencies. These actions are transparently hateful and in time will be judged as mistakes. In the mean time, policies like the one being approved here are going to do a lot harm. It's very unfortunate. We can do better. Finally, consider, however, that the policy cannot do away with the Constitution. This section in the policy is worth pointing out: "Constitutional Protections: Nothing in these guidelines shall be construed to infringe upon or affect a student’s core constitutional rights under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution or Article I, Section 8, of the Texas Constitution." And, just because this provision fails to mention the Texas and US Equal Protection clauses does NOT mean that students don't have equal protection rights. So, anti-DEI all you want, there are still going to be some protections. 765 kV update: On 9/11 the PUC Commissioners remanded two of the cases, 59185 (involving Irion Co.) and 59475 involving the line going east from Eldorado. A "remand" means they sent it back to the ALJs for more review...or, in other words, they didn't like the judges' ruling and want them to try again. The opinion on the table now provides that the applications for the lines should be denied, so this says something about where this is going... When I know more about the exact terms of the remand I will be filing an objection. I will post that on my 765 kV page. BoardBook is a significant advance because community members can subscribe to notices from the District and not only be advised of upcoming meetings, they can review and download the meeting documents before the meeting. So, if a community member wanted to advise the board of their opinion on a matter before the Board took any action, they could come to the meeting educated on their issue by reviewing the documents in advance. Seems revolutionary, doesn't it? Come prepared to a public meeting?! Well, it isn't. BoardBook is owned and managed by the Texas Association of School Boards, and it was launched back in 2002. School district boards have been using it for decades now, and thankfully IC ISD has joined up. It is a great decision. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Mertzon City Council September 14 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting The new coffee shop in town, Duke's Mercantile and Coffee, has an excellent out door table to watch the sun rise. A. Agenda Analysis Meeting time: This meeting is on the 14th at 6:30. Watch for my ICISD posting for their board meeting at 6:00 pm on the same day. Alley closure, item 6: This particular closure (which is distinct from an abandonment of the right of way) has a fact specific public safety basis tied to it. I'm going to forgo my usual ordinance and statutory analysis. Ordinances 20.02, 19.02 and 16.01, Items 7-9: Ordinance 20.02 appears to be a new agenda item, but the parades and block party ordinances are recent repeats. Marking the change of seasons. B. Meeting Review I was not able to attend this meeting because the IC ISD board meeting was at the same time. I will be reviewing an audio of the meeting and will post my highlights in the near future. C. Commentary Pending Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

  • Mertzon City Council August 24 2026

    Agenda Analysis | Meeting Review | Meeting Documents | Commentary | Last Meeting Speak out against the destruction of Big Bend National Park by our federal government. Big Bend NP is about 4 hours southwest of Mertzon. A. Agenda Analysis Public hearing, items 5 and 6: These are allotted times for the public to speak in open forum about the proposed City budget and tax rate. Adoption, items 7 and 8: These are the allotted times for the Council to vote to approve the budget and tax rate. Last year: Here is my page for this meeting in 2025. B. Meeting Review Here are the meeting documents, which includes the approved, almost final, budget. Public hearing, Items 5 & 6: No one from the public, other than myself, attended the meeting. I didn't speak. (This website is my forum.) Adoption of budget and tax rate, items 7&8: After some hesitation because the law requires they adopt a budget first and tax rate second, the Council approved both. See the meeting documents for the details. C. Commentary Did you know that the City of Mertzon, unlike Irion County ISD, did not pass a deficit budget? Why? First, the City doesn't face a recapture demon like the District. Every year the State takes funds from the District because it qualifies as "wealthy" under school finance laws from the mineral wealth in Irion County. The City doesn't share in any of that wealth, which also means that it doesn't share in the burden of a constant raiding of their coffers. Second, the City functions on very little debt, which means that their income is not going to interest payments like the District's. Indeed, with the latest round of bond issuance at the District, if they pay according to the 30 year schedule, the first 10 years or so will be interest only payments. Robert's Rules of Order: Most governmental entities follow them, but haven't "adopted" them formally. (That's a good thing.) A procedural issue came up in this meeting worth noting. What happens when the Council is obligated by law to pass a budget and tax rate, but none of the Council members are willing to make a motion to approve them? That awkward situation arose at this meeting when the Council bucked at the idea of passing a budget before the tax rate. The silence after Mayor Stewart asked if there was a motion was long enough that I wondered if they were going to take action. (They ultimately did approve both, in this case.) After conferring with Tax Assessor Collector Joyce Gray at this meeting, we agreed that the matter dies. That is, a matter on the table that doesn't get a motion and a second and a vote automatically fails because no action was taken. As she put it, they would have to start all over again. You won't find an answer to this type of issue in the Texas Open Meetings Act because it doesn't incorporate Robert's Rules. Robert's Rules typically apply by custom, so that is why one sees "motions" and "seconds" at public meetings. Robert's Rules also address "Discussion". Here's a tip, though not relevant to this meeting: Any member can end a discussion, say if folks have been going on too long, by saying, "I call the question". Procedurally, this ends the discussion and forces a vote. 765 kV cases: Watch for a Commentary update on my 765 kV page. At the time of this meeting, the ALJ recommended against granting the application for the line that goes through Irion County. But, the administrative process is still not over. Copyright 2026 G. Noelke

Drop Me a Line, Let Me Know What You Think

Thanks for submitting!

© 2025 by George Noelke

bottom of page